Eight inmates refusing food at Florida State Prisonan Associated Press report 2/02/04 STARKE - Eight inmates on the disciplinary wing at Florida State Prison are waging a hunger strike over what they claim are basic human needs for recreation, decent food, visitation and access to canteen items. According to the Florida Department of Corrections, eight of the 24 inmates on Q wing are participating in the strike, which began Sunday. A statement released by the inmates through the Florida Death Row Advocacy Group, states: "On Feb. 1, the inmates housed on Q wing will begin a hunger strike in protest of the erroneous and unconstitutional conditions that we are being forced to endure. Those who are not participating are either mentally ill or in fear of retaliation from this administration." The inmates claim conditions of their confinement are violating their constitutional rights. Seven conditions are listed on their letter:
Sterling Ivey, a spokesman for the Florida Department of Corrections, said the prison medical staff will monitor the condition of the prisoners participating in the hunger strike. Q Wing is a group of 24 cells on the second and third floor of the prison directly above the execution chamber. It is designed for use by inmates who break prison rules. The wing, on the far north end of the prison, used to be known as X wing. Death row inmate Frank Valdes was on X wing when he was beaten to death on July 17, 1999. Four guards were acquitted in two trials in the death of Valdes. Prosecutors, fearing they could not get a fair jury in Bradford County, where the prison system is the biggest employer, dropped charges against other guards.
WHP CBS21 [NEWS] - about ARAMARKJanuary 30, 2004 7:18 PM Officials are looking into whether a food service company is cutting back on the amount of food served to prisoners. Reporter Chris Schaffer has the exclusive story. When inmates come to the Dauphin County Prison food service giant Aramark provides the food they eat. A few months ago county officials began looking into the company's books, as part of a contract renewal process. They saw documents including years of menus, instructions, and budgets. Dauphin County Commissioner Jeff Haste: "The numbers didn't quite match up - it appeared in our minds that we had been over-billed" The county renewed its contract with Aramark. In early November, the prison went into a partial lock-down because of what the warden called "heightened tension levels" among inmates. At that time a corrections officer told WHP-CBS-21 that one factor leading to the increase in tension was that food portions appeared to be smaller. Another source now says documents suggest that for years, inmate portions have been reduced or watered down to save money. Soon the investigation will go before a grand jury in Dauphin County. A representative from Aramark would only say quote, "we did receive a request for information from the Dauphin County District Attorney's Office, and we are cooperating fully. Commissioner Haste says the discrepancies he noticed could be accounting errors, but; "If in fact there's criminal intent I'm going to recommend we prosecute to the extent we can prosecute" Aramark is a world-wide company, headquartered in Philadelphia. It provides food for sports stadiums, hospitals and universities in addition to more than 300 correctional facilities.
|
|
Doesn't he know???? How many times have I been asked:
|
To Mike, Kevin and Shagee:
To my darling Victor,
|
- By Dianne Abshire
I'm afraid I don't have much in the way of up-beat commentary this month. By the time this newsletter is distributed to most of you, February 4th will have come and gone, and the fate of our friend Johnny Robinson will be decided. We can only pray that justice is done, but we all know the odds aren't in his favor. If he is taken from us, a major miscarriage of justice will be carried out. In the words of Michael Radelet, renown sociologist and expert on capital punishment, if the planned execution of Johnny Robinson takes place, it will be, "one of the very most horrendous miscarriages of justice that I have seen anywhere in my 25 years in the business."
This observation is based on documented facts: Robinson was tried and convicted by an all-white jury for the murder of a white woman, Beverly St. George. The prosecutor, Steve Alexander, a racist by reputation, spoon fed his desired version of the murder to a then 16 year old mentally retarded child named Clinton Fields who was with Robinson at the time of the killing, was forced into signing a confession in 1985, and is now describing how he was pressured and bullied into signing what he knew was not the truth. In 1985 as a16 year old mentally retarded boy, Clinton Fields was believable. As a man in 2004, the adult Fields' recantation was dismissed by State prosecutors who continue to uphold his 1985 testimony as the truth, despite solid evidence to the contrary.
The tragic reality is that discrimination is still alive and well in our country. The case of Johnny Robinson is a prime example of the ills propagated by a biased and unfair judicial system that refuses to fix itself. Couple this accepted racism with the ineffective counsel of over a dozen attorneys who have represented Johnny Robinson over the years in a deliberate revolving-door method of replacement, and Johnny Robinson's death is inevitable.
1985 Florida was a racist environment where fear of repercussion drove Johnny Robinson to panic at the accidental shooting of a woman not of his race. Even more tragic is that in 2004, we can't get past these events placed into motion by racism and racist participants. We are unwilling to accept that racism played a part in unfair sentencing. In 2004 Dr. Radelet can still find new statistical evidence that courtroom racism still presides in St. Johns County. In the 7th Judicial Circuit, apparently the color of one's skin matters when determining who lives and who dies.
Our hearts go out to all of you who call Johnny "friend," both in-mates and out-mates.
February Birthdays
David Cook
|
A story of St. Valentine
|
What do you call a lawyer with an IQ of 50?
Your Honor.
What's the difference between God and a lawyer?
God doesn't think he's a lawyer.
Giving birth is like taking your lower lip and forcing it over your head.
-Carole Burnett
I only drink to steady my nerves. Sometimes I'm so steady I don't move for months.
-W. C Fields
If ignorance ever goes to $40 a barrel, I want drilling rights on George Bush's head.
-Jim Hightower, 1988
Americans always try to do the right thing -- after they've tried everything else.
-Winston Churchill
It is by the goodness of God that in our country we have those three unspeakably precious things: freedom of speech, freedom of conscience, and the prudence to never practice either of them.
-Mark Twain (about America)
I was so drunk last night I fell down and missed the floor.
-Dean Martin
If you ever see me getting beaten by the police, put down the video camera and come help me.
-Bobcat Goldthwait
If your eyes hurt after you drink coffee, you have to take the spoon out of the cup.
-Norm Crosby
I'm innocent, I'm not supposed to be here…
Because I am innocent I thought I had nothing to fear…
My lawyer slept in court, stayed drunk, and his breath reeked of weed and beer…
Poor, black, uneducated, an all white Jury should I fear…
My mother stood crying in court - I shed not a damn tear…
I lost my initial appeal then CCRC filed a notice to appear…
Damn I am in trouble now I must hold hope and faith near…
I received a letter from my woman, she said…dear…
The damn food is always cold…
The laundry is torn, dirty, and old…
The cells are nasty…
The pigs love to lie on me…
It is hot as hell…
The showers smell…
The 1996 death penalty act left us half dead…
Clemency is a damn joke to fuck with your head…
Registry appointed counsel is full of gas…
Jeb Bush murderer of women and children you are an ass…
We go to the law library and cant get any assistance…
We can't write free people for help, love, or support - this is nonsense
Ask Valdez isn't it legal for pigs to stump us to death in the cell…
Frank Smith an innocent man died in this hell…
Michael coleman has DNA evidence that proves he should be free…
The chaplain refused to send me cards because I used my real name Saifullah, damn Satan, Saifullah is me…
The state murdered Dez, Alma'ad, Shango, KC, knowing that they were not guilty…
I'm an illiterate retard so what the fuck do you think they will do to me…
This is death row tha motha fuckin' truth…
Submitted by Saifullah Yhuh UCI
Alone in this cage, nothing here
Only desolation, loneliness, and fear
Take my life, take my freedom
As they are; I don't need e'm
Pain permeates, deep inside of me
And all around as well
The lies, wrap themselves around me
My existence has become a living hell.
Believe what you will
It doesn't matter to me
Keep smiling as you kill
Death will set me free.
Poem and drawing submitted by Anthony LaMarca UC
U.S. judges will decide if high humidity levels and summer heat topping 95 degrees inside the state's death row amounts to a constitutional violation.
A panel of 3 federal appellate judges is weighing arguments about whether extreme summer heat and humidity on Florida's death row constitutes "cruel and unusual punishment."
At issue: If inmates are suffering because of indoor temperatures exceeding 95 degrees and a poor ventilation system at Union Correctional Institution in Raiford, is this an Eighth Amendment violation?
Elliot Scherker, an attorney with Greenberg Traurig representing the inmates, said Monday that the misery caused by the heat was just such a violation and that airflow should be improved.
But Caryl Kilinski, assistant state attorney general, said that misery was not enough to constitute "cruel and unusual punishment." The suffering, she said, had to be quantified by tangible, serious illness. Appellate Judge Rosemary Barkett asked Kilinski, "How can you require people to be totally miserable as long as there's no heart attack or brain tumor?" Kilinski, echoing the lower court decision of the late Ralph W. Nimmons Jr., a U.S. District Court judge, replied that "a risk of harm has to be shown."
Barkett said that she "didn't read it [the Eighth Amendment] that way."
In 2003, Nimmons ruled in favor of Kilinski and the Florida Department of Corrections, saying that despite a "restrictive and harsh" environment caused by the indoor heat and an admission by a corrections supervisor that the ventilation system "had trouble keeping up," the situation did not amount to cruel and unusual punishment.
To get through the summer, inmates on death row at UCI stand in their toilets, sleep on the concrete floors of their cells and wrap themselves in wet sheets.
A UCI psychologist said that she found it ''difficult to breathe" when she entered the unit.
But the problem "is not of constitutional magnitude," Kilinski insisted. The panel of appellate judges from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit -- Rosemary Barkett, Gerald Tjoflat and Eugene Siler - are expected to make a decision by late spring, before temperatures at UCI climb back into the 90s.
(source: Miami Herald)
|
by Dianne
Word about the hunger strike is getting out to the media. I received a phone call on February 3rd from AM 850 radio in Gainesville, requesting a phone interview which would air on their 4:00 p.m. broadcast on February 4th. At the time of this writing, I have no idea how much of the 15 minute discussion they'll use, or what portion of our talk they'll feel worthy of airplay. I'm sure they'll also have a DOC spokesperson on air as well to give their assessment of the situation, and I hope this person speaks as honestly about the situation as I tried to do. I tried to speak as fairly as I could about | the conditions that brought on the hunger strike at FSP. Besides speaking about the isolation, depravation, and other issues that prompted the strike, I stressed the need for humane treatment of those held in close management. They are all wards of the state, and as such, are required to be treated with a certain level of care, which is not being met. I hope I was able to speak competently for those who have no voice in their struggle, and hopefully the listeners will come to understand that the hunger strike is not over frivolous matters, as implied by certain media reports, but rather over serious issues of inhuman treatment of our fellow man. |
By Jim Ash, Palm Beach Post Staff Writer
Tuesday, January 20, 2004 TALLAHASSEE -- Florida's experiment to privatize the legal process that ushers condemned killers from Death Row to the execution chamber -- or freedom -- may be showing early signs of saving taxpayers money. Relying on private attorneys to defend some of Florida's Death Row inmates instead of using public defenders will save more than $2 million this year, state officials project.
"This is what the figures are showing," said Roger Maas, executive director of the Commission on Capital Cases. But critics say there hasn't been enough time to evaluate the success of what is supposed to be a three-year experiment.
"I think part of the problem you have with that is it's really something that is going to be hard to project," said Neal Dupree, a capital collateral regional attorney who faced the possible elimination of his job one year ago, when Gov. Jeb Bush released a bare-bones budget that proposed saving $9.3 million by eliminating the state's three Offices of Capital Collateral Regional Counsels. "You haven't lived until the day you wake up and see a big zero next to your agency's budget," Dupree said.
The offices, begun in 1985 to hasten the death row appeals process, are made up of 50 full-time attorneys paid by the state to represent death row inmates in their post-conviction appeals. Instead, Bush wanted to use defense lawyers from a list of private attorneys who are willing to accept a cap of $84,000 per case and a rate of $100 an hour. Lawmakers, including Bush's fellow Republicans, balked. A compromise was reached that eliminated only the North Florida region of the counsels and transferred its 64 cases to private attorneys. The north region office was eliminated June 30, wiping out its $3.2 million budget. Two of the cases landed in the lap of another region; private attorneys picked up the rest. In an interim report that is based on seven months of data and that has yet to be released, Maas predicts that the private attorneys in the north region will file only about $1 million in legal bills with the state. That puts the projected savings at potentially more than $2 million this year.
But Dupree, who serves in the state's southern capital collateral counsels region, says costs could grow exponentially as private attorneys take on more cases. Plus, Dupree said, the interim report doesn't take into account the fact that judges are allowed to increase the amount of money the private attorneys are paid, regardless of the state mandates, if the lawyers can demonstrate unusual circumstances. He also said the simple cost accounting says nothing about the quality of the work being done on a defendant's behalf or the speed at which the private attorneys have been able to do their jobs.
"It's nice to say there is a projected savings, but what has happened to these cases? If you're getting no movement in them, where's the bang for your buck?" The Capital Commission acknowledges it has not compared how quickly private attorneys are doing the work compared to their regional counselbrethren. But some state legislators said they were encouraged by the Capital Commission's projections.
"I'm pleasantly surprised. While I was hopeful, quite frankly, I was skeptical," said Sen. Victor Crist, R-Tampa, who helped negotiate the compromise. Others remain skeptical of the privatization effort. It's "dumbing down the appellate process," said Rep. Dan Gelber, D-Miami Beach, a former federal prosecutor who supports the death penalty but is an ardent foe of dismantling the Capital Collateral Regional Counsels network. Collateral reviews of death row cases, considered the most complex area of criminal law, begin only after a defendant has exhausted his direct appeals.
Post-conviction petitions are usually based on the narrow grounds of new evidence, ineffective trial counsel, misconduct by prosecutors, faulty or recanted eyewitness accounts or a defendant's retardation or other mental incapacity.
Collateral reviews amount to starting the criminal case all over again, often requiring thousands of hours to review tens of thousands of pages of court documents and re-interview crucial witnesses. The state registry, which now includes 147 private attorneys, was originally created to give judges a place to go when a Capital Collateral Regional Counsels office became overloaded or had to turn down a defendant because of a potential conflict of interest. To qualify for the state registry, attorneys need only minimal experience, including a continuing education course on capital cases and a record of having tried at least five felony cases. In comparison, most Capital Collateral Regional Counsels attorneys have been trying these complicated cases for years. "If they make mistakes," Gelber said of the private attorneys, "we have to reload and start from scratch. It's a relatively small amount of money to save when you risk so much in the long term." Critics of the death penalty also are not impressed by the early returns. "It becomes a question of what lawyers are willing to do the work and at what cost. Some will do it because it's close to their heart," said Abraham Bonowitz, director of the Jupiter-based Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty. "Others will do enough work to satisfy the bill that the state is willing to pay." The latter will ultimately lead to increased mistakes in the death row appeals process and the eventual execution of innocent defendants, Bonowitz said. Since the death penalty was reinstated in Florida in 1979, 24 Death Row inmates have been exonerated. Bonowitz called the privatization experiment "bogus" when compared with a calculation made by The Palm Beach Post in 2000 that eliminating the death penalty altogether and substituting life in prison without parole would save the state $51 million a year. "If they really want to save money, they will eliminate the death penalty," he said.
"What they are doing is putting innocent lives at risk and they are putting the reputation of the state at risk, and what have they accomplished?" Bush is expected to introduce his budget for 2004 today, and it remains to be seen whether he will again push to eliminate the remaining regional counsels. A spokesman did not respond to requests for an interview. But even Crist, a Bush supporter, said he would not go along with speeding up the experiment." There just hasn't been enough time to decide," Crist said.
Randy Schoenwetter FSP
The Visitation by Frank Peretti
Lancelot Armstrong UCI
Evil in Modern Thought, Susan Neiman
Michael Rivera UCI
Conversos, Inquisition by Norman Roth
Timothy Robinson UCI
Destruction of the Black civilization
by Chancelor Williams
James Ducket FSP
Ultimate Punishment by Scott Turow
Franklin Floyd UCI
Rising Tide by Gary Weir /Walter Boyne
From a Buick 8 by Stephen king
Jim Rose UCI
Runaway Jury by Grisham
Four Blind Mice by Patterson
Each month, FDRAG will collect book wishes from the readers of our Newsletter.
In order to submit a book wish, simply fill out the form below, send it to FDRAG and your book may be one of the 10 book titles which will be drawn each month, and purchased via Amazon.com.
Because we want this program to benefit as many as possible on our shoe-string budget we ask that you pass on your book when you're done reading it.
Share-A-BookName:DOC: Housing:Author:Title: |
This group is created by families and friends of death row inmates in Florida. It is a given that this group is against Capital punishment. It is however, not the purpose for this group to do anti-death penalty work, instead this group concentrates on making the living conditions for death row inmates tolerable. We also commit to work on making changes that will improve the quality of living in that particular environment called Death Row, and to help keeping the standard that already exists. Everyone who is willing to work for basic human rights is welcome. If you are looking for a group who does anti-death penalty work, we suggest you join one of the excellent groups already up and running. For further information please contact a member near you:
Hannah Floyd, (Can be contacted for info on newsletter, membership, visiting,
places to stay, transport etc.)
137 N Walnut St, #14
Starke, FL 32091
E-mail: Hannahfloyd@yahoo.com
Tel: 904-964-4303 or 904 964 7303
Janice Figueroa
1120 Wild Oak Terrace
Deland, FL. 32720
E-mail: Tfigu@aol.com
Tel: 386-738-3968
Karin Elsea, (Contact person for the DC/Maryland area)
1400 East West Highway, #710
Silver Spring, MD 20910
E-mail: Karinelsea@hotmail.com
Tel: 301-565-3246
Dianne Abshire
9673 State Rt 65
Ottawa, OH 45875
E-mail: afua@woh.rr.com
Tel: 419-523-5816
(Can also be contacted re: legal matters for the attention of Florida Support Group)
Jolanda Arends, Treilerstraat 168
NL - 1503 JM Zaandam
E-mail: jolanda-arends@zonnet.nl
Tel: +31-75-616-4862
(FDRAG membership and info pack)
Florida Death Row Advocacy Group114856 SE 25th AvenueStarke Florida 32091
Copyright ©2005 FDRAG - All rights reserved. |
Please help us by supporting FDRAG. |